The Feedlot: Beef Cattle and the Finishing System
What it is
A feedlot is a confined outdoor facility in which beef cattle are fed a high-energy grain-based diet to accelerate their growth and fatten them for slaughter. Most beef cattle in the United States and many other industrial beef-producing nations spend the final three to six months of their lives in feedlot conditions, producing the well-marbled, consistently flavored beef that American consumers recognize as the standard.
History & domestication
Cattle finishing — the practice of feeding cattle grain before slaughter to add weight and marbling — has roots in pre-industrial agriculture, but the modern feedlot as an industrial institution developed in the American Midwest and Great Plains from the 1950s through the 1980s. The geography was not accidental: the Corn Belt of Iowa, Illinois, Nebraska, and Kansas produces enormous surpluses of corn; the feedlot is, among other things, a mechanism for converting surplus grain into protein calories at industrial scale. The cattle come primarily from ranches in the Western states, where they graze on pasture — often public lands managed by the Bureau of Land Management — for the first portion of their lives before being trucked to feedlots for finishing.
The largest feedlots are almost incomprehensibly large. The Five Rivers Cattle Company, a subsidiary of JBS USA, operates feedlots in Colorado, Kansas, Texas, and Idaho with a combined one-time capacity of approximately 900,000 head. A single large feedlot pen may hold 200 to 500 cattle in a few acres of unpaved or concrete-surfaced outdoor space, with no shade, minimal environmental enrichment, and access only to the feed delivered mechanically to bunks along the pen perimeter.
The diet of a feedlot steer is a radical departure from the animal's evolutionary diet. Cattle evolved as ruminants — animals whose four-chambered stomachs evolved to ferment and digest cellulosic plant material, primarily grass. The rumen (first stomach) is a fermentation chamber populated by bacteria, fungi, and protozoa that break down cellulose; the system evolved over millions of years in a context of grass. Feedlot rations are typically 70% to 90% grain (predominantly corn and sometimes sorghum), supplemented with protein sources (soybean meal, cottonseed), roughage (typically corn silage or hay in small proportions), and a suite of additives including ionophores (a class of antibiotics that improve feed efficiency), beta-agonists, vitamins, and minerals.
The physiological consequences of a grain-heavy diet on a ruminant digestive system are significant. Acidosis — a lowering of the pH in the rumen due to the rapid fermentation of starch — is endemic in feedlot cattle. Mild acidosis is essentially universal; severe acute acidosis can be fatal. The condition causes inflammation of the rumen wall, liver abscesses (visible at slaughter), and a range of other systemic effects. Feedlot cattle are routinely monitored and treated for acidosis-related conditions; a low-level chronically acidotic state is considered a production management challenge rather than a welfare problem by the industry, though animal welfare scientists have noted the implications.
Ecological role
The feedlot model of beef production has profound ecological implications. The grain required to finish a pound of beef represents a significant land, water, and energy investment. The most commonly cited conversion figure — that it takes approximately 7 pounds of grain to produce 1 pound of beef weight gain — is an approximation that depends on production system and animal genetics, but the general principle of significant feed conversion losses is not contested. This has direct implications for global food security: the grain that passes through feedlot cattle could theoretically feed many more humans directly than the beef it produces.
Water use in beef production, particularly in feedlot systems, is substantial. Estimates of the water footprint of beef production vary considerably depending on methodology, but peer-reviewed analyses typically place the water footprint of a kilogram of beef at between 5,000 and 20,000 liters — an order of magnitude more than the water footprint of plant proteins. In regions where feedlots overlay major aquifers — including the Ogallala aquifer underlying the Great Plains — the water demands of both the animals and the feed crops represent a draw on a finite and substantially non-renewable resource.
Reference notes
Cross-link to: Grass-Fed vs. Grain-Fed Beef, Beef in American Culture, The Ogallala Aquifer, Feedlot vs. Pasture Production, Beef Water Footprint.
---